Brooklyn Pizza

Reviews

• Nina O.

  star star star star star 9 June 2026

  If you are serious about your pizza, this place is a must go to. Be prepared for your eyes to roll back in your head from joy when you bite into their pizza. Their sauce is spectacular and so is the cheese and crust. Went to pick up some hero sandwiches for a picnic and waited for a pizza while my son munched on a plate of fries. My resistance towards anything made from dough, cheese and fattening foods was destroyed by the time I came home, when I served my child a slice of pizza and the pizza scent entered my brain and entrapped me. Embarrassingly so, I lost control and inhaled three slices of pizza like a nebulzing treatment. I had to fight  with myself to stop eating. It was that good. They serve large sandwiches and salads. Whether you keep kosher or not, this place has the highest quality of ingredients. If you think I'm exaggerating, order the barbeque sauce pizza with deep fried onions. It brings new meaning to the loss of mind control.

• Abasin S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 7 June 2026

  Negative experience here twice, staff not friendly and almost rude. Did not like the pizza sauce way too much garlic.

• Rand L.

  star star star star star 1 June 2026

  Fantastic pizza shop. Unique selections. To start, we had the garlic knots which came out hot and tasty. Instead of going the safe route and having a simple cheese pizza, I decided to have the Boro Park Pizza which had bbq sauce and crispy fried onions it. Very different and very good. The staff was also super friendly and attentive during our visit. I highly recommend!

• Meyer G.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  Pizza was decent. Staff very nice. Could have put a little more of the toppings that we requested.  Computer is set up to always request tip when you sign for the charge. I'm not sure of proper etiquette so left tips each time even though I'm not sure if it was warranted or not as mostly self service.

• Lydia T.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  This place is great. I came with friends on a Sunday afternoon and spent over three hours here chatting and enjoying the pizza.
  
  The employees were friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was great. The bathroom was clean. Most importantly, the pizza was delish.
  
  We tried two different pizzas and both were fantastic. The crust was crisp and not soggy and it all tasted great. Don't expect to get meat on your pizza though, this place is kosher (yaaaas!) and vegetarian.
  
  I wish these guys were in my home town because I'd be a regular.
  
  The only thing that I would recommend changing would be the size of the paper cups they provide for water. Those things were teensy tiny and I must have had to walk back and forth from my table to the water dispenser 8 to 10 times while I was there. :-D What can I say? Pizza makes me thirsty!